How to reply to "I'll think about it"
By Coach Victor
"I'll think about it" usually means one of three things: they have a question they didn't ask, they're not sure it'll work for them, or the timing is off.
Your reply has one job: make it easy for them to tell you which one. Pushing back makes them shut down. Curiosity gets them talking.
Got one of these right now? Tell me what they said and I'll write 3 replies for you, free. →Respect it, then get curious
Start by saying "totally fair" or "of course". People relax when they don't feel pushed.
Then ask one gentle question about what they're weighing. Often there's a simple worry you can help with.
The gentle question
Of course, take your time! Is there anything you're unsure about that I can help with?
The honest one
Totally fair. Can I ask what part you're thinking over? Sometimes I can make that part easier.
The "what would help"
Sounds good! What would help you decide: more details, hearing how it worked for someone else, or just time?
The easy timeline
No rush at all 😊 Want me to check back in a few days, or would you rather reach out when you're ready?
The friendly out
Of course! And if it's not the right time, that's totally OK too. I'd rather you say no than feel pushed.
When they tell you the real reason
Money: ask what would make it worth it, or whether a smaller start would help.
Not sure it'll work: share a real story from someone like them, or offer a small first step.
Timing: agree on when to check back, and actually do it.
🚫 What not to send
- Don't argue or list more features.
- Don't invent urgency like "price goes up tomorrow" when it doesn't.
- Don't just say "OK, let me know!" That ends the conversation.
- Don't disappear. Agree on when you'll check back.
Questions people ask
Is "I'll think about it" a polite no?
Sometimes, but usually it means they have a question or a worry they didn't say out loud. A kind, curious question will tell you which.
When should I follow up after "I'll think about it"?
Ask them when it would be good to check back. If they don't say, two or three days is a good first follow-up.
Want replies written for your exact message?
Examples are a start. Tell me what they said and what you offer, and I'll write 3 replies that fit, plus what to say next.
Write my replies ✍️
Ask Coach Victor